Every year or so, a beloved title from the New York Times’ Best Seller List is greenlit for the royal Hollywood treatment. This fate is not always for the best. In fact, the proverbial glass is often half-empty. For every critical darling, there is also an ill-portrayed pariah.  Thus, adaptations, like any surgery, must be done with great care.

For the record: The Help is far more than a tale of sisterhood. Any characterization as such unfairly diminishes the moral, spiritual, cultural and political elements that hang in the balance. Nevertheless, media outlets have branded the film as a light-hearted work of historical fiction, despite the fact that its primary focal point is the unveiling of hardships endured by black domestic servants – during a period of tense social and political transition – in Jackson, Mississippi. The unlikely friendship forged between Skeeter (Emma Stone), Aibileen (Viola Davis) and Minny (Octavia Spencer) is simply an elegant window treatment to a doctrine of courage we must challenge ourselves to embrace in the midst of life’s challenges.

Very few authors have the talent of Kathryn Stockett. She paints such vivid pictures with her words that it would seem impossible to capture their totality on the moving screen. Considering the wide-ranging social issues presented, from civil rights to positive parenting, any attempt to refine the raw elements would have had a compromising effect on the screenplay. Fortunately, the film provides a balanced account with conflicting perspectives – never once sugarcoating the worst or overplaying the best of Southern life during the Jim Crow era. The realistic plausibility of several poignant scenes will tinker with every viewer’s heartstrings – forcibly extolling a few laughs, tears, screams and shouts.

In the face of such weighty material, who better to write the screenplay for “The Help” than Stockett’s childhood friend, Tate Taylor? Only an intimate acquaintance has the power and insight to articulate the thoughts, desires and emotions as the original creator intended. Taking the novel’s length by the horn, Taylor collapsed multiple scenes into singular ones with magnificent ease – fighting to safeguard as much content as humanly possible within the film’s running time of 146 minutes. For example, the introduction of Aibileen’s prayer notebook runs parallel with her first interview session with Skeeter. While condensing of this sort does not wreak havoc on the plot’s cohesion, viewers who have read the novel may frown upon the absence of the humorous anecdotes connected to Aibileen’s powerful “super prayers.”

In addition to Tate Taylor’s focused direction, praise must also be given to Kerry Barden and Paul Schnee for selecting a cast above reproach. From the stars in the foreground to the extras in the background, every member played their part as if they were portraying their own lives. The casting of Cicely Tyson in the role of Constantine is significant and noteworthy. With over five decades of acting experience, she says more with her facial expressions and body language than with the scripted text. In each scene where Tyson appears, the spotlight is hers alone. Coupled with similar outstanding performances from Viola Davis and Octavia Spencer, these actresses delicately balance warmth and humor amidst the film’s serious undertones.

No matter the outcome of all forthcoming Oscar prospects or box office receipts, Tate Taylor’s masterful adaptation of Kathryn Stockett’s work has guaranteed its status as a contemporary literary and film classic.

[SPECIAL NOTE – added 08/11/11: Authors of historical fiction tend to suffer a backlash when the issue of “accuracy” comes into play. Although I disagree with critics who speak of “The Help” negatively, there is much to be said about the lack of documented [non-fiction] accounts. According to the Association of Black Women Historians: during the ’60, “[u]p to 90 per cent of working black women in the South labored as domestic servants in white homes.” Considering the singular commonality of the black, Southern, female experience, there is plenty of room in the social narrative of “The Help” for both – historical truth alongside literary/cinematic masterpiece.]

Advertisements
Comments
  1. chadeharris says:

    Well said. Beautiful point about courage. The freedom Aibileen feels at the end of the novel sticks with me more than anything else. And as I sat after seeing the film, the idea of courage was at the forefront of my mind. And then I thought, of course—it makes perfect sense. It takes courage to be free.

    Taylor certainly does do a remarkable job placing the pivotal moments from the novel into well-crafted scenes. I had sort of a checklist in my head, anxious to find out how he handled each of my favorite parts which I felt just had to be in the movie. I was utterly pleased.

    And yes, such a delicious cast! Jessica Chastain captured Celia perfectly. I saw much of what you said of Cicely Tyson in Octavia Spencer. She gave me chills. Excellent work from all of them. Truly.

    • crperry84 says:

      Upon reflection, I must agree with your take on this “delicious” cast. I will be keeping my eye open for any/all upcoming roles from Jessica Chastain and Bryce Dallas Howard. I just realized how much “Celia” made me laugh – and that “Hilly” deserved the entire serving of Minny’s special pie! LOL…

  2. I heard Kathryn speak at a book signing. I was amazed to hear that she received more than 60 rejections for the novel, as I thought it was fabulous. I was hoping that the film would remain true to the book and I was not disappointed. I did wonder if I would have followed the story if I hadn’t read the book, though. I understand a prequel is in the works. I’m eager to read that as well. Nice review!

    • crperry84 says:

      Young, “unproven” writers are no stranger to criticism and naysayers littering the path to “overnight” success. I am happy that Kathryn did not let Rejection #1 deter her from publishing this incredible novel – let alone Rejection #60! (Yikes.) Her determination to prevail against the odds is quite the tale of inspiration, too!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s